Mayor hits back at fluoride ‘disinformation’

Max Frethey - Local Democracy Reporter

Opponents to drinking water fluoridation have previously protested the council for following its directive from the Ministry of Health. Photo: Max Frethey.

Nelson Mayor Nick Smith has hit back at “disinformation” being spread on social media about fluoride in the city’s water.

Outdoors and Freedom Party co-leader, Sue Grey, had applied to speak during the public forum of Thursday morning’s Nelson City Council meeting to adopt its annual report.

Sue’s application was sought following a post to the party’s Facebook page a day prior alleged that Nelson had started fluoridating its water supply, after the party claimed to have measured fluoride at 0.98 parts per million in the city’s drinking water.

During Thursday’s meeting, the mayor dismissed the allegation as “disinformation” which was “completely false”.

After gaining an extension, Nelson is now required by the Ministry of Health to fluoridate its water by 31 December. Nick, while running through the agenda at the beginning of the meeting, said there were no applications to speak in the public forum that were consistent with the council’s standing orders – the rules for the conduct of council meetings.

Sue objected, standing up and approaching elected members, saying that she had applied to speak.

However, Nick was firm in his denial of her speaking at the public forum.

“The standing orders are very clear, it’s in black and white, and that is that any application to present in public forum must be received at least two days prior to the meeting. Your application was received yesterday afternoon,” he said.
Sue, a lawyer, requested that the mayor use his discretion as chair of the meeting to allow her to speak – which he is able to do – but Nick maintained his position.

“Your behaviour is disorderly,” he said. “It is not right, Sue, any more in court than in council, for you to stand where you are and to interrogate me as mayor. Councillors are entitled to do so, you are not.”

Nick also labelled the claim that the city was already fluoridating its drinking water as “disinformation” which was “completely false”, with fluoridation not occurring until after the council’s December meeting.

He added that opponents to fluoridation were scheduled to speak on the topic at the December meeting, ahead of the Ministry’s deadline. Sue, along with several supporters, left after Nick threatened to have her removed from the building if she did not allow the meeting to continue.

Two cries of “disgrace” and “shame” were thrown by supporters as they left.

Speaking immediately after leaving the council chamber, Sue said the situation was “unbelievable”.

“We asked to be heard, and they just refused. It’s an astonishing lack of democracy, and lack of respect for the rule of law.”

Sue Grey was denied speaking at Thursday's council meeting because her application was lodged too soon before the meeting. Photo: Max Frethey.

Sue said she wanted to talk with the council to ensure “our rights are listened to. This council, led by Nick Smith, is not even interested in listening to the concern.”
The Ministry of Health supports community water fluoridation as a safe, effective, and affordable way of preventing tooth decay.

Then Director-General of Health Ashley Bloomfield also said, when he directed Nelson to fluoridate its drinking water in 2022, that it would be “an important step in improving the oral health” of the city.

Local Democracy Reporting is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air

Get local news delivered to your inbox

Stay informed with what’s happening in Nelson/Tasman with a free weekly newsletter. Delivered to your inbox every Friday morning, the Nelson App newsletter recaps the week that’s been while highlighting what’s coming up over the weekend.

* indicates required